Hotel is an amazing experience in relation to the converted convent. I paid for the larger room and it was very comfortable, typical Italian hotel room, beautiful typical Tuscan interior and furnishings. No kettle but I've not yet found an Italian hotel that offers a kettle, they're not big on tea or instant coffee. Pool area is beautiful but bear in mind it is open as a pay as you go pool to the public. We requested the train station shuttle in advance and were told to get a taxi instead (at a cost of 14 euros), both ways this added to 2/3s the nightly room rate so not too happy about that considering the Hotels.com listing specifies the complementary service. We were also told at 5pm that the restaurant was closed to accommodate a wedding, which, considering the hotel is in the middle of the mountains 3 miles to the nearest shop and 2 miles to the nearest bus stop, was quite an oversight. We had luckily brought a few snacks with us for the evening.
We were also told on arrival that we required swimming caps to go in the pool and that we pay 2 euros each for these so another unexpected expense. The staff seemed to be very reluctant to provide customer service, but that's my experience of Italian hotels in general.
This is a beautiful place to get some relaxation, peace and spectacular views the Tuscan hills but there is not really a "holiday vibe" to it. Guests don't seem to hang around the common areas so you don't really get to be around others aside from breakfast.